Welcome to Johnny's New York Style Pizza Atlanta
Johnny's New York Style Pizza Atlanta brings an authentic taste of New York to the heart of Atlanta. Located conveniently on Chattahoochee Ave, this vibrant eatery is renowned for its delicious pizza, characterized by a perfectly crisp yet chewy crust and generous toppings. Customers rave about the freshness and quality of ingredients in every dish, from their classic pepperoni to the savory Greek salads. The inviting atmosphere is enhanced by friendly service and a casual vibe, making it a perfect spot for a quick bite or family dinner. Plus, with daily drink specials, it's an ideal destination for pizza lovers seeking great value.
Johnny's New York Style Pizza Atlanta: Reviews & Ratings
The food was delicious and the service was great. We ordered the Greek salad, wings, and a large pizza. Everything was fresh, hot, and came out quick. We will definitely be back and recommend for anyone looking for a good slice. I didn't get a drink but they also have a bar and daily drink specials with items 5 or less.
Five Stars! I stopped by this pizza spot and ordered the large pepperoni—and wow, it did not disappoint! The crust was perfectly baked, with that ideal balance of crispy and chewy. The pepperoni had just the right amount of spice and crisp around the edges, and they didn't skimp on the cheese either. Everything tasted fresh and flavorful. Friendly service and quick turnaround made the experience even better. Definitely coming back!
Visited Johnny’s New York Style Pizza for a quick snack or slice. Customer service is always friendly and nice. Lots of variety of options to pick from the menu, that’s why I like this restaurant. My pizzas have always been delicious . Great price, great pizza, great customer service. I recommend this restaurant.
Coming from NY this is one of the closest to NY style pizza that I have found around the city. The staff was very friendly and provided great service. I love the location, it’s got a casual NY vibe with its own Atlanta twist to it. I also like that the sliding doors can be open for when the weather is nice. If you want some quality pizza, some sides, and drinks at a good price this is the spot to go.
Johnny’s Pizza never disappoints! Every time I order, the food comes out piping hot and fresh, just the way it should be. You can really tell they take pride in what they do—from the perfectly melted cheese to the crispy crust, everything hits the spot. They never miss! Whether it’s a quick slice or a full order for the family, it’s always 10 out of 10. Highly recommend!
Arrived around 1:30AM and had THE BEST experience!! The food was incredibly well made: pasta perfectly cooked, sauce well seasoned, calzone crispy. Our server was super hospitable and came out with our food quickly. The vibe inside is also really fun, with a mural depicting the ATL skyline and other important points of interest in the city and popular music. Can't believe we had this good of a time!
Our new go-to neighborhood pizza spot! The mini garlic knots are so yummy! And you really can’t go wrong with a large classic cheese pizza. The service is always great and the food hot. We will be regulars here!
Service was amazing in atmosphere altogether was very inviting. Cake was bussing af. 10/10 They’re big fans Bruno mars’ music 10/10. Server makes you laugh, sick mustache, authentic, and real. 10/10 GET THE RED VELVET CAKE. IT SO GOOD. BEST DESSERT IN ATL
Location
-
1465 Chattahoochee Ave NW #850, Atlanta, GA 30318, United States Hotline: +1 404-603-8043
Welcome to Johnny's New York Style Pizza Atlanta, an enticing culinary destination nestled in the heart of Atlanta at 1465 Chattahoochee Ave NW #850. This pizzeria transcends the ordinary with its authentic New York-style pizza, paired with friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere that captivates both locals and visitors alike.
As you step through the doors, you are greeted by a lively ambiance that exudes a casual New York vibe, beautifully infused with a unique Southern twist. The sliding doors invite the outside in, making it an ideal spot to enjoy a delicious slice on a sunny day. The menu boasts an impressive variety of options, catering to all tastes—from crispy, chewy crusts to an array of toppings that dazzle the palate.
Customer reviews speak volumes about the quality here. Take, for instance, A Kemp, who raved about the Greek salad, wings, and large pizza, highlighting their freshness and quick service—a testament to the kitchen's efficiency. Then there's Chris Terry, who awarded five stars for his large pepperoni pizza, emphasizing the perfectly baked crust and rich, flavorful toppings.
What truly sets Johnny's apart is not just the food but the commitment to customer satisfaction. As Morgan Tochi noted, the consistent friendly service and great pricing add to the overall experience, making it a beloved spot for quick snacks or family meals. For those craving authentic New York-style pizza, Nick T advocates that this pizzeria comes remarkably close to what one would find in the bustling streets of NYC.
The atmosphere, coupled with piping hot, fresh dishes—from perfectly melted cheese to that sought-after crispy crust—creates a blissful dining experience. Royce Burley sums it up perfectly: "They never miss!" Visitors consistently leave satisfied, eager to return for another bite. With daily drink specials and a welcoming bar area, it’s not just about the pizza; it’s a community gathering spot.
In a world filled with dining options, Johnny's New York Style Pizza Atlanta stands out. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or sitting down for a hearty meal with loved ones, you're bound to experience quality that resonates with every bite. For pizza lovers and newcomers alike, this pizzeria is a must-visit—a slice of New York in the heart of Atlanta!